resourcesABOUT MT AUTHOR GUIDELINES CLASSIFIEDS EDITORIAL CALENDAR MEDIA GUIDE MASSAGE MART SCHOOLS & EDUCATION FEEDBACK
Calcium Helps Prevent Colorectal Cancer
Over the past 25 to 30 years, studies have suggested calcium may confer protection against colorectal cancer.
The X Factor in Clinical Research: The Patient
It was the great baseball legend, former New York Yankees catcher Yogi Berra – he of countless aphorisms, each with a mind-bending twist – who once declared, "You can observe a lot by watching."
Healing With TCM at San Quentin State Prison
For the prisoners at San Quentin State Prison, life-sentences are the reality of every day life. It is not often that prisoners get the opportunity to use alternative medicine to deal with common ailments they encounter behind bars such as, depression, anxiety and pain.
Managing Patient Expectations About Acupuncture
Last year, I attended the Pacific Symposium in San Diego for the first time in six or seven years. It was the 25th anniversary of this event, and on one evening there was a panel discussion with the title; "What is Qi?."
Lime Jello on Morphine
Taste is in the eyes... actually the mouth... of the beholder. My food preferences have changed, lightening from the food of my youth. My parents loved heavy eastern European cuisine and I loved it as a child. Now I enjoy leaner, healthier whole foods.
Saying No to Medicine
An interesting article recently appeared in Men's Journal titled "When to Say No to Your Doctor." The article begins with the summary statement above and effectively arms readers with information that will help them "take more responsibility for your own health care, because you can't be sure anyone else is.
Understanding and Identifying Pediatric Growth-Plate Fractures
In general, fractures in children heal well with little intervention as long as the alignment is good. Fractures involving the growth plate, however, are a different issue. In fact, growth-plate injuries are the primary reason for the subspecialty of pediatric orthopedics.
Pulse Diagnosis: What We Know
I am still finding pearls of wisdom from the books and papers that I inherited from my pulse diagnosis mentor Jim Ramholz.
Web Marketing: Content Is King
Google's sweeping updates to its search algorithms over the past few years have brought a paradigm shift in how you can optimize your chiropractic website to gain maximum marketing leverage.
AOMA Strengthens Leadership Team
AOMA Graduate School of Integrative Medicine, a leading college of acupuncture & herbal medicine, announced the appointment of Donna LaPoint Hurta, MBA as the new VP of Finance & Operations this Fall.
Simple Ways To Find True Happiness
Patients in our clinics are always seeking happiness. As their health advocate, we need to ensure we inform them that in order to find happiness, they have to make sure to identify what makes them happy in the first place.
Jingei Diagnosis: An Effective and Powerful Diagnostic
I graduated from the Kotatama Institute under the direction of Drs. Masahilo and Katsuharu Nakazono in 1984. As a student, I was exposed to the practice of most of the various theories and modalites of Oriental Medicine.
Transparency and Accountability: Q&A With the CCE
Every profession needs an organization dedicated to upholding the quality and integrity of its degree programs and educational institutions.
Help Patients Achieve Optimal Vitamin D Levels
Much research has been done on vitamin D levels and their impact on health; optimal levels have been correlated with a reduced risk of developing numerous conditions.
Talking to Patients About Healthy Aging
I've noticed that a particular category of patients seems to make up more and more of my practice – they work out, but still experience lots of degenerative joint disease (DJD) issues.
Managing Today's Fertility Patient
I recently received an email from one of my fertility patients: "Got my lab results back. FSH is 11, AMH is 0.7. My doctor said these numbers aren't good. I guess I'm infertile. Just as a thought. Just set up an appointment to speak with an adoption agency."
Blaming the Gluteus Medius, Overlooking the Deltoid
The gluteus medius (Gmed) is commonly written about, strengthened and blamed for many conditions, and rightfully so. After all, the Gmed plays a role in pelvic stability, hip motor control and lower-quarter dynamic movements.
To The Finish Line With the Help of TCM
When acupuncturist Eddy De Smedt pursued a career in Traditional Chinese Medicine, he knew he wanted to make a difference.
5 Ways to Occupy Occupational Health
Despite the progress that has been made to better protect workers, occupational health and safety remains a priority area for many national governmental organizations due to the widespread problem of occupationally related morbidity and mortality.
The Tao of Gender
If you think gender is as simple as having a new client check off the "male" or "female" box on your intake form, we hope this article will expand your understanding and thus the reach of your health care.
The Heart Protector
On the physical level, the Pericardium is a double-layered sac of fibrous tissue that envelops the Heart. The space between the layers is filled with serous fluid that protects the Heart from external shock or trauma and lubricates to allow for normal Heart movement.
August, 2008, Vol. 08, Issue 08
Don't Get Married, Part 2
By Erik Dalton, PhD
Humans are designed to move in order to survive - locomotion must precede all other activities. The past few decades have witnessed the emergence of two diverse schools of thought, each with their own biomechanical explanations detailing the seemingly simple act of walking.
Both disciplines generally agree that cross-patterned gait (opposite arm and leg moving at the same time) is a normal function of walking and running. However, advocates of the traditional "pedestrian model of gait" insist the legs are the main-event in locomotion and upright walking is a basic design where the legs propel the passive passenger - the trunk - through space. Pedestrian model groupies tend to lump the torso, arms and head together and generally dismiss the upper body as a critical player in gait mechanics.
As discussed in part 1 (Feb. 2008 issue), Canadian nuclear physicist Serge Gracovetsky, PhD, rebuked the pedestrian model by declaring that counter-rotation of the shoulders and pelvis is an essential key to locomotion and force is not generated by the legs, but instead arises through a complex muscle/skeletal interaction propelled by what he calls a "spinal engine."1 He further explains, "Evolutionarily, locomotion was first achieved by the motion of the spine. ... The legs came afterward as an improvement, not as a substitute."
If Gracovetsky's theory that the spine is the primary engine driving the pelvis has "legs to stand on" (no pun intended), then manual therapy assessments and rehabilitative corrections must be modified accordingly. Since low back pain is the most common disability among people under the age of 45, the consequence of this reinterpretation of spinal function could be far-reaching. Today, researchers and clinicians worldwide are experimenting with Gracovetsky's intriguing hypothesis.
Tempted to Marry
Since both schools of thought are supported by sound research in the gait-analysis community, I'm trying hard not to marry a single model of locomotion. To prevent the suffering that accompanies divorce, I've developed assessments and corrections based on gait studies conducted by two renowned experts in the field, Serge Gracovetsky and my mentor, Philip Greenman.2 This osteopathic and physics collaboration paints a broader, more comprehensive picture of the walking cycle. Unfortunately, in the process of marrying the two methods, some of Gracovetsky's brilliant spinal-engine concepts have been altered. To avoid misrepresenting the views of either researcher, the proposed model in part 2 will simply be referenced as the "myoskeletal engine."
The Myth of Leg Locomotion
Dr. Gracovetsky convincingly asserts, "If the legs were truly the mobilizing force propelling the body through space, a competitive sprinter with huge powerful legs and a small torso should be the fastest." (Figure 1) Obviously, this image does not fit the picture we'll see at the Beijing Olympic Games or even in the photo of a 21-year-old South African double-amputee runner Oscar Pistorius, who finished second against the world's top athletes in a 400-meter race at the Golden League Meet last year in Rome. (Figure 2)
Initial observation of Pistorius' stride reveals a rhythmic cross-patterned gait and strong pelvic/shoulder counter-rotation that appears as the driving force propelling his lower extremities. Figures 3A and 3B illustrate global and core muscle "slings" that store and release kinetic and elastic energy that help him run at such high speeds. In the absence of lower legs and feet, one might conclude these anterior and posterior spring systems alone provide enough thrust to propel Pistorius' pelvis and extremities. But apparently, the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF) disagreed. They voted to ban him from formal competition based on the conclusion this artificial "springing" mechanism somehow amplified his interaction with gravitational ground forces.
Appeals to the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) and subsequent studies confirmed the carbon-fiber blades did not give him an unfair advantage. So, does Pistorius run fast because of the recoil delivered by curved blades, or are humans endowed with a similar recovery pulse capable of transmitting gravitational forces up the kinetic chain to enhance power in the other spring systems?
Flat Tire - Flat Foot
Since the human body relishes energy conservation, it's reasonable to assume kinetic (movement) energy shouldn't be lost into the ground as described in the pedestrian gait model. Gracovetsky uses the analogy of running in sand versus on a firm surface to make a point that efficient movement demands a recovery pulse that springs from the arch, up the leg and through the pelvis and torso to help drive the spinal engine. Furthermore, it makes sense that any "kink" along this myofascial or skeletal (myoskeletal) chain would be reflected as a kink elsewhere in the system that would only serve to slow down the engine.
For example, if a car has a low tire and the tread begins wearing unevenly, the vehicle will begin to shake sooner or later. As the vibration makes its way through the suspension system, the tie rods start working loose. If left untreated, damage spreads to the motor mounts. Eventually, the "shaky" engine sputters to a halt. Although the low tire was the root of the problem, it's tempting to blame the engine because the car no longer runs.
In this regard, it's easy to see how a deflated tire might perpetuate a chain of events manifesting as compensations elsewhere. To remove kink(s) from the system, an experienced mechanic won't immediately pull the hood and begin checking for loose spark plugs and battery cables. Tracking down the dysfunction typically starts by consulting with the owner, conducting a thorough history of onset, symptoms, etc., and then performing a detailed inspection that leads to the "key lesion" - the low tire. From information garnered during the evaluation process, the mechanic is able to systematically work their way though the suspension system, motor mounts and fuel-injection system to restore optimal motor functioning.
The same applies to the client with a flat foot and short leg. A good body mechanic doesn't treat a hyperpronated foot in isolation but looks for compensations along the kinetic chain that might have developed as a result of the shortened extremity. Kinks traveling from the head down (TMJ, O-A, scoliosis, cranial distortion, etc.) are labeled descending syndromes, while asymmetry caused by pronated feet, short legs, knock-knees, etc. are referred to as ascending syndromes. (Figure 4) Any soft-tissue or bony compensation that distorts the vertebral column's S-shaped curve will overwork the anterior and posterior spring systems, resulting in stress and pain.
Stirrup Spring System
The automobile analogy provides a nice segue for introducing a third biomechanical "sling" critical in driving the myoskeletal engine. Known as the stirrup spring system (SSS), this antigravity propulsion pump delivers energy from the tibialis anterior/peroneus longus stirrup through the biceps femoris and sacrum to provide rotary torque that "winds up" intervertebral joints and deep collagen structures. Figure 5 depicts a few key SSS muscles activated during running. Although, I agree with Gracovetsky that efficient movement requires humans to possess some kind of recovery pulse to avoid loss of kinetic energy into the ground during gait, the biomechanics of how that pulse is delivered is debatable.
Gait analysis is best understood when viewed just prior to heel strike, as illustrated in Figure 5. For the SSS to achieve optimum elastic recoil, two neurologically driven maneuvers must orchestrate in perfect harmony. With hip extensors (biceps femoris and G-max) maximally stretched:
Walking and running trigger various degrees of force through the stirrup, knee, lateral thigh, biceps femoris and sacrotuberous ligament. The amount of force at heel strike determines how much lumbopelvic counter-rotation takes place and what muscles/ligaments are recruited. Once the pulse reaches the pelvis, the mechanics become more complex.
At this point, Gracovetsky and I part ways. He believes the recovery pulse at right heel strike possesses sufficient strength to travel unimpeded up the leg, through the sacrotuberous and long dorsal sacroiliac ligaments, and into the ipsilateral multifidi, longissimus and iliocostalis. Erector spinae contraction then causes right lumbar sidebending and reciprocal pelvic counter-rotation. Although this intriguing firing order does play a major role in running, it differs a bit from my interpretation of Greenman's heel strike mechanics during walking.
Myoskeletal Engine Possibility
Notice in Greenman's illustration (Box 1, Figures 1 and 2) at right heel strike, the sacrum, pelvis and lumbar spine are all left rotated. This implies that during the walking cycle, heel strike probably doesn't transmit adequate force to sidebend the lumbars and counter-rotate the pelvis, as Gracovetsky infers. A myoskeletal-engine firing order that seems to best fit Greenman's illustration has the stirrup pulse traveling through the biceps femoris and sacrotuberous ligament, tugging on the lateral sacral angle, and (with help from the quadratus femoris and G-max), left-rotating the entire pelvic bowl in a transverse plane.
Gracovetsky's spinal engine theory is based on the assumption humans possess no muscles capable of directly rotating the pelvis. But if one follows the chain of events beginning at heel strike to the stance phase, it appears the sacrum and pelvis perform complex maneuvers enhanced by many smaller but extremely important muscles that do possess the capability to directly and indirectly rotate the pelvis. At first glance, it seems an insignificant point, so long as the final result is a smooth cross-patterned gait. However, it implies the possibility of a different SSS firing-order pattern traveling through the lumbopelvis and thus the need for alternative assessment and treatment sequences.
Stance Phase Is True Coupled Motion
The myoskeletal SSS theory relies on Harrison Fryette's 1st Law of Spinal Motion3 which (paraphrasing) states that in the presence of normal lumbar lordosis, vertebral and sacral rotation and sidebending occurs to opposite sides. (Figure 6) Gracovetsky believes this coupled motion takes place at heel strike and I see it happening during the stance phase. In my model, the following actions occur during the one-legged stance phase (right limb):
Last, but not least, the lateral spring system (LSS) depicted in Figure 8 might be one of the most unappreciated of all the body's antigravity structures.
Driven by the hip's abductors, this elegant myofascial gait-enhancer "cocks' the ipsilateral innominate and, just prior to push-off, right-sidebends the rotating pelvis so the other three spring systems can smoothly swing the left leg through. (Box 1, Figure 5) All is well if gluteus medius and minimus are properly toned and firing in correct sequence. Regrettably, this spring system commonly is skewed as other abductor muscles overpower the weak glutes.
Figure 9 illustrates the need for greater contralateral OL recruitment in athletes such as hurdlers and running backs. However, during normal gait, both quadratus muscles should be relatively silent. Thus, the ideal abduction firing-order pattern from stance through toe-off should be: gluteus medius/minimus; co-contraction of the ipsilateral adductors; tensor fascia latae; piriformis (synergistic stabilizer) and quadratus lumborum.
A greatly underestimated source of discogenic and facet joint pain arises when the ipsilateral QL fires first, "hip-hikes" the innominate, and forces the ipsilateral leg to try to swing through.
These people walk like a block with a labored gait. Seen in many golfers and other athletes who participate in one-sided sports, this common QL substitution pattern is quite easy to assess and correct. Figures 10A and 10B demonstrate two QL releases that help drag down a hip-hiked (posteriorly rotated) ilium. Unfortunately, fixing the QL problem won't completely restore proper firing order if the glute medius/minimus are weak. Fast-paced spindle-stim techniques and "clam" home re-training exercises using resistance tubing are a simple solution. Although most clients like deep gluteal massage and stretching, these traditional bodywork maneuvers alter the hip-abductor firing order and destabilize the pelvis. Weak glutes = future hip replacements.
Sports and the Spring Systems
Many athletes (and therapists) believe if a little stretch is good, more is better. Bombarding the physiologic barriers through over-stretching and excessive deep-tissue work not only jeopardizes ligamentous stability, but also causes loss of recoil and balance in the body's intricate spring systems. No one questions that chronically shortened (fibrosed) tendons, fascia, ligaments and joint capsules require restoration of flexibility, but what about weak, overstretched and neurologically inhibited tissues? Certain structures such as the thoracolumbar and lower abdominal fascia must retain a certain amount of stiffness to store and release elastic energy while providing core stability. Myofibroblast receptors embedded in deep fascial tissues might prove to be the missing link responsible for enhancing power in the four spring systems.4 See Box 2 for spring-system balancing tips.
Fast-paced myoskeletal spindle-stimulating techniques combined with Vladimir Janda's upper- and lower-crossed syndrome balancing routines are a complementary and essential starting point in the myoskeletal engine method. Tonifying typically weak muscles via "spindle-stim" maneuvers and home re-training exercises helps establish proper firing-order patterns while restoring cross-patterned gait. Loss of reciprocal (coupled) motion between the lumbar spine and sacrum probably is the leading cause of chronic low back pain. A testament to this assertion is the fact the L5-S1 intervertebral disc receives more surgical procedures than any other spinal segment. Bottom line: Discs hate sustained compression but love storing and releasing rotary torque.
The theoretical approaches presented in this two-part series represent an ongoing personal journey into the captivating world of gait. Attempting to blend Gracovetsky and Greenman's gait-analysis theories has opened a Pandora's Box of additional inquiries questioning how ascending and descending syndromes (flat feet, TMJ, knee injuries, etc.) destabilize pelvic and lumbar spine balance. What seems clear is the necessity for restoring perfect coordination and antigravity function to all four spring systems. Energy conservation during walking or running demands all systems fire in a precise order at just the right moment to accomplish this task. I've become married to the idea that all the body's global and core structures must work harmoniously to produce rhythmic and effortless movement during normal activities and athletic endeavors. Try experimenting with spring system balancing routines and elevate your hurting clients and competing athletics to a new level of health.
Click here for more information about Erik Dalton, PhD.
Join the conversation
Comments are encouraged, but you must follow our User Agreementcomments powered by Disqus
Keep it civil and stay on topic. No profanity, vulgar, racist or hateful comments or personal attacks. Anyone who chooses to exercise poor judgement will be blocked. By posting your comment, you agree to allow MPA Media the right to republish your name and comment in additional MPA Media publications without any notification or payment.